Categories: Bathroom Remodeling

Cheapest Shower Remodel Options

Cheapest Shower Remodel: What Chicagoland Homeowners Should Know Before Updating Their Bathroom

The cheapest shower remodel isn’t always the one with the lowest upfront cost—it’s the option that gives you long-term value without sacrificing durability. Immediately, many homeowners assume replacing their old tub or shower will be expensive, but several cost-efficient approaches can modernize your bathroom without a full gut renovation. Additionally, keeping your existing layout is one of the smartest ways to control costs.

At Envy Home Services, we help Chicagoland homeowners—from retirees like Martha to busy empty nesters like Ray & Kathy—understand what truly affects the price of a bathroom remodel. Moreover, we take pride in guiding you through materials, installation, and design with clear, accessible explanations. If you’re thinking about upgrading your shower, we’re here to help you choose the best option for your home and budget.

What Is Considered the Cheapest Shower Remodel?

The cheapest shower remodel is one where you keep the layout exactly the same. That means:

  • If you currently have a tub, replace it with a new tub.
  • If you have a shower, replace it with a new shower.

Furthermore, leaving all plumbing, drains, and walls in place eliminates expensive labor and structural changes. Additionally, choosing the right wall system plays a major role in cost—and long-term performance.

Why Acrylic Is the Most Cost-Effective Option (Even If It’s Not the Cheapest Upfront)

Many homeowners initially believe that fiberglass surrounds are the cheapest route. Technically, this is true—fiberglass is typically the lowest-cost shower wall system. However, it’s also the least durable, which means higher long-term expenses.

Why Fiberglass Falls Short

  • Scratches easily
  • Stains quickly
  • Often yellows over time
  • Difficult to repair
  • Shorter lifespan

Additionally, fiberglass tends to crack or show wear after only a few years, leading to costly replacements. Consequently, what seems like the cheapest shower remodel now often becomes the most expensive in the long run.

Why Acrylic Is the Best “Cheapest” Choice

Acrylic costs slightly more upfront than fiberglass, but it lasts significantly longer.

Acrylic systems offer:

  • High durability
  • Stain resistance
  • Easy cleaning
  • Nonporous surfaces that resist mold
  • Long lifespan without fading or cracking

Moreover, acrylic systems can mimic the look of tile or stone without the heavy maintenance. Because of these advantages, acrylic offers the best combination of affordability and longevity—making it the best true cheapest shower remodel option.

The Most Expensive Option: Tile Surrounds

On the other end of the budget spectrum sits tile. Tile is beautiful, customizable, and timeless—but also labor-intensive and costly.

Why Tile Showers Cost More

  • Requires professional installation
  • Must be carefully waterproofed
  • Involves detailed labor
  • High material cost depending on tile selection

Additionally, tile surrounds require ongoing upkeep: grout sealing, crack checks, and mold prevention. While stunning, tile is best suited for homeowners prioritizing luxury aesthetics and long-term “wow factor,” rather than those seeking the cheapest shower remodel.

How Layout Impacts the Cost of Your Shower Remodel

Keeping your existing configuration is one of the biggest ways to reduce costs. Moreover, changing layouts adds plumbing, structural work, and additional permits.

Examples of Cost-Efficient Upgrades

  • Tub to new tub (no plumbing changes)
  • Shower to new shower (same footprint)
  • Updated surround and fixtures without moving lines

Additionally, Envy Home Services helps homeowners determine whether their layout should stay the same—or whether small changes could add value without blowing the budget.

When Layout Changes Cost More

  • Moving a drain
  • Converting a tub to a shower or vice versa
  • Redoing subfloor or framing
  • Reconfiguring the bathroom footprint

Consequently, maintaining the existing layout is key for anyone specifically seeking the cheapest shower remodel option.

Why an Envy Home Services Bathroom Remodel Makes Sense

A bathroom remodel can feel overwhelming, especially for homeowners who aren’t sure where to begin. Fortunately, Envy Home Services specializes in breaking down the process so it feels manageable and stress-free.

We Help You Choose the Right Material

Additionally, our team explains every material—fiberglass, acrylic, tile—so you fully understand cost, longevity, maintenance, and design differences.

We Offer Full-Service or À-La-Carte Options

  • Want us to handle everything? No problem.
  • Want to purchase your own fixtures or materials? We support that too.

Moreover, our flexibility allows you to control costs while still getting expert installation.

We Respect Every Home’s Unique Needs

Retirees like Martha appreciate our knowledgeable, patient guidance—especially when accessibility upgrades such as grab bars or low-threshold showers are part of the plan. Meanwhile, busy couples like Ray & Kathy rely on us to manage the process from start to finish so they don’t have to.

Veteran-Owned Values

Furthermore, our veteran-owned and operated company is committed to professionalism, honesty, and durable craftsmanship. We believe every homeowner deserves a safe, well-built, and easy-to-maintain bathroom.

Recommended Images for This Blog

  • Acrylic shower wall system close-up (landscape 1200×628)
  • Side-by-side comparison: fiberglass vs. acrylic vs. tile (square 1080×1080)
  • Modern acrylic shower replacement in a Chicagoland home (portrait 1080×1350)

Ready to Choose the Best Shower Remodel for Your Budget?

The cheapest shower remodel isn’t just about upfront price—it’s about long-term durability, functionality, and smart planning. Keeping your layout as-is and choosing a high-quality acrylic system gives you the best value without sacrificing beauty or performance.

Interested in remodeling your shower? Contact Envy Home Services for a free in-home quote!

Envy Home Services

Recent Posts

Designing an Aging-in-Place Bathroom Without Sacrificing Style

Designing a bathroom that supports aging in place no longer means settling for a sterile…

2 weeks ago

The Ultimate Guide to Kitchen Backsplash

Choosing the perfect kitchen backsplash is both an art and a science. It's the element…

2 weeks ago

How to Choose a Color Palette for Your Bathroom

Choosing the right color palette for your bathroom can completely transform it from a purely functional space…

3 weeks ago