What Is the Cheapest Way to Redo a Shower? A Complete Guide to Shower Remodel Cost for Chicagoland Homeowners

Redesigning your shower can dramatically improve the comfort, safety, and appearance of your bathroom. However, many homeowners worry that a bathroom renovation automatically means a massive expense. Fortunately, that’s not always true. The cheapest shower remodel is about smart planning—not cutting corners.

At Envy Home Services, we help Chicagoland homeowners understand how layout, materials, and labor choices directly impact shower remodel cost. Whether you’re a retiree planning to age in place or an empty nester upgrading for resale value, this guide will help you make confident, cost-effective decisions.

Most importantly, if you understand where money is truly spent, you can remodel your shower without unnecessary surprises.

What Is Considered the Cheapest Shower Remodel?

The cheapest shower remodel is one that keeps your existing layout exactly the same.

In other words:

• If you currently have a tub, replace it with a new tub

• If you currently have a shower, replace it with a new shower

By keeping plumbing, drains, and walls in place, you immediately avoid the most expensive part of any bathroom renovation—structural and plumbing changes. As a result, your shower remodel cost stays significantly lower.

Additionally, choosing the right wall system plays a major role in both upfront cost and long-term value.

Why Shower Remodel Cost Varies So Much

Before choosing materials, it’s important to understand what actually drives cost. Although many homeowners focus on finishes, labor is often the largest expense.

The Three Biggest Cost Factors

1. Labor complexity

2. Material selection

3. Layout changes

Consequently, even “budget” materials can become expensive if the installation is complicated.

Labor: The Hidden Cost in Every Shower Remodel

Labor is the single largest contributor to shower remodel cost. Therefore, minimizing labor-intensive work is key to staying on budget.

What Increases Labor Costs?

• Removing a bathtub and converting to a shower

• Moving or widening drains

• Replacing valves and plumbing lines

• Extensive demolition and waterproofing

Because plumbing must meet local village code, these tasks require experienced professionals. While DIY may seem appealing, improper installation can lead to leaks, mold, and expensive repairs later.

As a result, hiring a skilled contractor is often the most cost-effective long-term decision.

Material Options Ranked by Shower Remodel Cost

Lowest Budget Option: Shower Inserts or Surrounds

Shower inserts are prefabricated units made from fiberglass or acrylic. They are often sold at big-box stores and appeal to homeowners looking for a quick update.

Pros

• Lowest upfront cost

• Fast installation

• Minimal disruption

Cons

• Limited customization

• Fiberglass scratches and stains easily

• Shorter lifespan

Although fiberglass is technically the cheapest upfront option, it often becomes more expensive over time due to wear and replacement.

Best Value Option: Acrylic Shower Wall Systems

Acrylic wall systems are widely considered the best balance of affordability and durability.

Why Acrylic Is the Smart Choice

• Durable and nonporous

• Resistant to mold and mildew

• Easy to clean (no grout)

• Long lifespan

• Faster installation = lower labor cost

Moreover, acrylic systems can mimic tile or stone without the maintenance headaches. Because of this, acrylic consistently delivers the best long-term value for homeowners focused on shower remodel cost.

Most Expensive Option: Custom Tile Showers

Tile showers are beautiful and customizable. However, they are also the most labor-intensive option.

Why Tile Costs More

• Extensive demolition

• Waterproofing steps

• Tile setting and grouting

• Ongoing maintenance

Additionally, grout requires regular sealing and cleaning. While tile offers a luxury aesthetic, it is best reserved for homeowners prioritizing design over budget.

One-Piece vs. Four-Piece Shower Systems

Although one-piece showers look seamless, they are not always ideal—especially in older Chicagoland homes.

Why Four-Piece Systems Are Often Better

• Easier to install in tight spaces

• Allow for natural house movement

• Less risk of cracking

• More forgiving in older homes

As a result, four-piece acrylic systems are often safer, more durable, and more cost-effective over time.

Tub-to-Shower Conversions: How They Impact Shower Remodel Cost

Converting a tub into a walk-in shower is a popular upgrade, especially for accessibility. However, it does increase cost compared to a simple replacement.

Typical Cost Ranges

• Budget surround conversion: $4,600–$5,800

• Acrylic four-piece system: $5,800–$7,100

• Custom tile shower: $7,100–$9,200

Costs vary based on plumbing changes, drain size, and material choice. Therefore, keeping expectations realistic helps avoid sticker shock.

Keeping Your Existing Bathtub to Save Money

If your bathtub is structurally sound, keeping it in place and replacing only the walls is one of the cheapest ways to redo a shower area.

When It Makes Sense to Keep the Tub

• The tub is in good condition

• You want minimal disruption

• Budget is a priority

• You want a faster timeline

Because demolition and plumbing changes are eliminated, this approach can dramatically reduce shower remodel cost.

Maintenance Costs Matter More Than You Think

Upfront price is only part of the equation. Long-term maintenance also affects the true cost of a shower remodel.

Acrylic vs. Tile Maintenance

• Tile: grout sealing, scrubbing, mold prevention

• Acrylic: wipe clean with mild soap

Over time, acrylic saves both money and effort—especially for homeowners planning to age in place.

DIY vs. Professional Installation

While some pre-fabricated systems are DIY-friendly, showers are one of the riskiest areas for mistakes.

DIY Risks Include

• Leaks behind walls

• Improper waterproofing

• Mold growth

• Voided warranties

Therefore, even budget-conscious homeowners often choose professional installation to protect their investment.

Why Envy Home Services Is the Right Choice

At Envy Home Services, we believe every homeowner deserves a well-built, well-maintained home.

What Sets Us Apart

• Veteran-owned and operated

• Licensed and insured

• Full-service or à-la-carte options

• Clear, no-nonsense pricing

We even allow homeowners to bring their own materials if they want to cut costs. Additionally, we guide you through every decision so you feel confident—not overwhelmed.

Final Thoughts: Choosing the Cheapest Shower Remodel That Lasts

The cheapest shower remodel is not about choosing the lowest sticker price—it’s about choosing materials and layouts that last.

By keeping your layout, selecting acrylic wall systems, and working with experienced professionals, you control shower remodel cost while still achieving a beautiful, durable result.

If you’re ready to explore your options, contact Envy Home Services today for a free in-home consultation. Let our veteran-owned team help you remodel smarter, not harder.

Your shower should work for your life—and your budget.